Sophie Cunningham wasted no time fitting in with Caitlin Clark and the Indiana Fever during the 2025 WNBA season. After being traded from the Phoenix Mercury in a multi-team deal, the move marked a fresh start for Cunningham following six seasons in Phoenix. New city, new teammates, and quickly, new connections that went beyond basketball.
That chemistry didn’t stop on the court. Cunningham formed a close bond with Clark and naturally became familiar with those in Clark’s inner circle, including her longtime boyfriend, Connor McCaffery. As the season progressed, it was clear the relationships within the Fever locker room were strong and genuine.
When McCaffery posted a rare and emotional Instagram message celebrating Clark’s birthday, fans flooded the comments with love and curiosity. Cunningham joined in with a question many people were already thinking but hadn’t asked out loud: what exactly did he get Clark for her birthday?
Her playful comment instantly stood out and added a lighthearted moment to the post. While Clark replied with a warm and affectionate message, McCaffery kept the mystery alive by not revealing the gift. That only fueled more fan reactions and engagement around the post.
Off the court, roster questions remain. Clark is locked in with Indiana through 2027, providing stability for the franchise. Cunningham, however, is currently without a contract after completing her one-year deal. If the Fever want to keep one of Clark’s most vocal supporters and on-court enforcers, contract talks will need to happen before the next WNBA season tips off.
About the Author
