Idiana Fever guard Sophie Cunningham may face an uncertain offseason as the team prioritizes re-signing star guard Kelsey Mitchell. Cunningham joined the Fever in February 2025 through a historic multi-team trade that reshaped both her former team, the Phoenix Mercury, and Indiana. Fever general manager Amber Cox described her as a “perfect fit” to complement Caitlin Clark, and Cunningham quickly earned a reputation as Clark’s “enforcer,” known for her versatility, physical defense, and sharp three-point shooting.
Unfortunately, Cunningham’s season was cut short in August due to a knee injury, and by that point, Clark was also sidelined. Despite the setbacks, the Fever made a deep playoff run, finishing just one game shy of the WNBA Finals. However, with Cunningham entering unrestricted free agency, the team’s roster could see significant changes in 2026, potentially placing her on a different squad.
Looking ahead to free agency, Indiana has made it clear that Kelsey Mitchell is the organization’s top priority. Both GM Cox and head coach Stephanie White emphasized the importance of re-signing the three-time All-Star. White praised Mitchell’s consistency and leadership, stating that her performance throughout the season was “instrumental” and that she continues to grow despite being eight years into her career.
Cunningham, meanwhile, remains a highly sought-after player around the league. She finished the season averaging 12.2 points per game and shot a career-best 43% from three-point range, demonstrating her value as a scoring threat. Fully aware of her worth, Cunningham has expressed a desire for a substantial contract rather than a short-term deal, especially with the upcoming WNBA collective bargaining agreement expected to raise player salaries.
On her Show Me Something podcast, Cunningham shared her outlook:
> “The next team I play for, I want a bigger contract, so then I can buy a house and be cozy. It could be anywhere.”
With her combination of skill, versatility, and veteran experience, Cunningham is poised to attract interest from multiple teams, making her one of the most intriguing players to watch in the 2026 free agency class. Indiana’s focus on Mitchell may shift the landscape, but Cunningham’s talent ensures she will have options as she navigates the next chapter of her career.
